Ohio AG Looking for New Leads in 2006 Piketon Homicides

"This is a case where we are certain someone knows exactly who killed these two people," said Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine.  "Anyone with information should come forward and help authorities take this killer off the streets."

The bodies of the engaged couple were found in the home they shared at 124 Hopper Road in Piketon.  Both victims were asleep when they were shot.

"He was always a very soft hearted person who was good to everyone," said Francis' mother, Judy Conley.  "Jennifer was like a daughter to me.  They had just started making plans for a family."

Agents with the Attorney General's Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI) are assisting the Pike County Sheriff's Office with the investigation. 

"Our detectives worked on this case until they exhausted every single lead, and now BCI agents are looking at the investigation with a fresh set of eyes," said Pike County Sheriff Richard Henderson.  "This case has been open long enough.  We need to get this solved and help give the families some closure."

Authorities said they believe more than one person witnessed the killings and that the person who pulled the trigger likely knew the couple.

Conley believes the person responsible was after medication recently prescribed to her son.

"Curtis had recently had shoulder replacement surgery and was taking Percocet," Conley said.  "I always told him he was too trusting, and I think he trusted the wrong person with that information."

Investigators said they believe it is possible the gunman is also responsible for at least one other homicide.

"We need to stop this killer before he takes even more lives," said DeWine.  "Even the smallest detail of information on this case could be the information that leads to an arrest."

"Not knowing who killed my son for six years is one of the worst things a mother can go through," said Conley.  "If someone is arrested I think I would finally be able to sleep at night."